Chikhalidwe cha tsopano cha kukana sayansi chimapitirira ku HIV
Ngakhale kupititsa patsogolo tsiku ndi tsiku mu sayansi ya kachirombo ka HIV , mthunzi wa kukana kwa Edzi kumadalirabe kwakukulu, kukayika kukayikira ndi kusokoneza pakati pa iwo omwe nthawi zambiri amafunikira chisamaliro.
Ngakhale kuti mawu akuluakulu otsutsa (Peter Duesberg, Celia Farber) sangathe kugwira ntchito yawunivesite yomwe idakhala nayo zaka za m'ma 1980 ndi 90-pamene panalibe podziwika bwino za HIV ndi mantha. za sayansi yolondola - mauthenga awo ndi njira zawo zimakhudzidwa lero.
Kuchotsa malingaliro awo ngati "quackery" yachipatala kapena zochepa za zaka zochepa zosazindikirika zomwe zimawopsyeza kwambiri kuti kukana kumakhudza momwe anthu amamvera kachilombo ka HIV, komanso mantha omwe amatsutsana nawo.
Posachedwapa mu 2007, kafukufuku wopangidwa ndi bungwe la US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) anasonyeza kuti 51 peresenti ya amuna ochepa omwe amagonana ndi amuna (MSM) adagwirizana ndi mawu akuti "HIV siyambitsa AIDS."
Kafukufuku amasonyeza kuti malingaliro a chiwembu pakati pa gululi sikuti amatsutsidwa kwambiri ndi zikhulupiriro zosatsutsika payekha, koma ndi maganizo olakwika okhudza kugwiritsira ntchito kondomu , komanso kudana kwakukulu kwa boma ndi / kapena chithandizo cha zaumoyo.
Kodi Kudana ndi Edzi Kumayambira Kuti?
Malingana ndi Oxford Dictionary, munthu wokana "ndi munthu amene amakana kuvomereza choonadi cha lingaliro kapena malingaliro omwe amatsimikiziridwa ndi umboni wambiri wa sayansi kapena mbiriyakale."
Chris Hoofnagle, wotsogolera ntchito wamkulu wa Samuelson Law, Technology & Public Clinic Clinic ku yunivesite ya California, Berkeley, akutanthauzira kuti:
"Popeza kukambirana movomerezeka sikuli koyenera kwa iwo amene ali ndi chidwi choteteza malingaliro akuluakulu kapena opanda nzeru kuchokera ku sayansi, chokhacho chimagwiritsa ntchito ... njira zamakono."
Zina mwa njira zowonongeka zomwe Tara C. Smith, wothandizira pulofesa wina wa pa yunivesite ya Iowa College of Health, ndi Dr. Steven Novella wa Yale University School of Medicine anaphatikizapo
- Kuwonetsa sayansi yowonjezera ngati kuti yanyalanyaza nzeru kapena yogwidwa ndi chidwi (mwachitsanzo, kukondera ndi "ndalama za mankhwala").
- Kusankha mwadongosolo omwe akuluakulu akukhulupilira ndi omwe angachotsedwe kuti akonze chigwirizano chachinyengo, kapena kutsimikizira kuti sayansi yotsimikiziridwa ikutsutsana.
- Kutsimikizira momwe chiphunzitso cha sayansi chinatsutsika ndi chiphunzitso cholimba (nthawi zambiri chizunzidwa), pamene chidziwitso chavomerezeka cha sayansi chimatsutsana ndi kupondereza.
- "Pewani chikhomo" mwa kufuna umboni wochuluka wa sayansi kuposa momwe ulili pakali pano, ndiyeno ndikuumirira pa umboni watsopano pamene zofunazo zatha.
Kuvulazidwa?
Pakalipano, anthu omwe amavomereza chikhulupiliro chokhwima nthawi zambiri amawonekeratu kukhala osatetezedwa ndi chinyengo kapena chinyengo, kapena kusowa maphunziro omwe akufunikira kuti adziwe chidziwitso chodziwika bwino. Kafukufuku wochokera ku yunivesite ya Connecticut akuwoneka kuti akunena zosiyana.
Ogwiritsa ntchito intaneti mu phunziroli omwe adavomereza chikhulupiliro china chotsutsa za Edzi, kuwerengera kwa chikhulupiliro ndi kukhulupirira kunali kwakukulu kwa webusaiti yambiri ya zachipatala (Tufts Medical School) kuposa ma webusaiti awiri otsutsa omwe adawonetsedwa (Matthias Rath, Jonathan Campbell).
Izi zikuwoneka kuti zikusonyeza kuti mauthenga otsutsa sakulimbikitsa kwambiri chikhulupiliro chaumwini, komabe zitsimikizirani kukayikira ndi kukayikira kwa iwo omwe safuna (kapena osakhoza) kulandira chithandizo chamankhwala pazochita zawo zabwino.
Malinga ndi kafukufuku wopangidwa ndi CDC, ndi anthu 44 pa 100 alionse omwe ali ndi HIV omwe ali ndi kachilombo ka HIV amathandizidwa ndi chithandizo chamankhwala. Zolakwa zokhudzana ndi kachilombo ka HIV zokhudzana ndi kachirombo ka HIV komanso kusakhala ndi kachilombo ka HIV zimayesedwa chifukwa chachikulu chomwe amachitiramo chifukwa cha kuchepetsa mankhwala mpaka chiyambi cha matenda opatsirana .
Choncho ngakhale kuti kunyalanyaza kwa Edzi kungawonekere ngati mbiri yakale kwa ena, kuthekera kwake kuti asokonezeke ndi kusokonezabe kumakhalabe kolimba ngati kale.
Zotsatira:
Kalichman, S .; Eaton, L .; ndi Cherry, C. "Palibe umboni wakuti kachilombo ka HIV kamayambitsa matenda a Edzi": Kutaya magazi kwa Edzi Zikhulupiriro pakati pa anthu okhala ndi HIV / AIDS. "December 2010, 33 (6): 342-440 (Table 3).
Skarbinski, J ;; Furlow-Parmley, C ;; ndi Frazie, E. "Woimira Padziko Lonse Akuwerengera Chiwerengero cha Akuluakulu a HIV + Okalamba Amene Amalandira Chithandizo Chamankhwala, Anapatsidwa Zachilombo ka ART, ndi Pulogalamu Yowonongeka Kwachidakwa, 2009 mpaka 2010." Msonkhano wa 19 wa Retroviruses ndi Matenda Osakanikirana (CROI); Seattle, Washington; March 8, 2013; ndemanga yomveka # 138.